I’ve written before about the frustration of trying to keep a canoe straight and about the techniques that make paddling smoother, from the forward stroke through to the elusive J-stroke. Those two PaddleMag articles were all about the mechanics: how to get from zigzags and bickering to gliding with grace and efficiency. Looking back now, I can see they weren’t just about strokes and pivots; they were about patience, communication, and the quiet satisfaction that comes when everything finally clicks. This blog is a chance to revisit those lessons with a bit more reflection, and to share what I’ve learned since about teaching, paddling, and why I think canoes keep us humble.
Learning to Paddle, Learning to Teach
If you asked me whether I remember my first frustrating attempts to paddle a canoe in a straight line, I’d have to say I don’t. And I have to check myself because I subscribe to that idea that sometimes the best person to teach something is the person who's most recently learned it. They can talk about the awkward stage, the clumsy stage, the click-into-place stage. When I can’t recall that early struggle, I have to compensate. So, I carry around twenty-five different ways to explain any one skill and I switch depending on the person in front of me. If I say it one way and their brain whirs and nothing changes on the water, I try another way. And another. The goal is simple: make it land.
I learned to paddle long before I ever learned to teach, and the difference shows. Teaching well is not just about knowing a stroke, it’s understanding how people learn. Some people need to watch. Some need to do. Some need to hear it. Most need a mix. I’m grateful for the methods I’ve been shown over the years because they turn a big, mysterious skill into a small, achievable step.
The joke that breaks the ice
In the original Paddle Mag article, I called canoes “divorce machines”. It was a joke then and it is a joke now, but there’s truth in it. I’ve even had to separate my own parents mid-paddle when wind and opinions picked up! At Valley Outdoors we hire a lot of canoes to couples, and that line breaks the ice. Then we explain why the tension happens.
A canoe gives each paddler a different role and, by design, an unequal amount of influence on where the boat goes. It’s not about who is smarter or stronger. It’s about where you sit; leverage matters. We tell pairs this before they set off, then check in when they return: are you still talking to each other? It always gets a laugh, and it opens the door to a quick bit of learning that makes the next outing smoother.
Why canoes feel harder than kayaks
People often ask why canoes feel trickier than kayaks at the start and I’ll be honest with them and tell them the truth. A canoe can be a bit of a pig. Most of ours don’t have a keel. Nothing is helping you go straight. We hand you a single-bladed paddle and ask you to paddle on opposite side and there’s no rudder. One paddler will naturally have more turning power than the other. It can sound like tying your shoelaces together and being told to go for a run.
So why do I love it? Because mastering a canoe is rewarding and oddly romantic. It does not take long either. Day in and day out we brief beginners on the bank, push them off, and watch them find success far quicker than they expected. The knowledge gap looks like a canyon when you have never seen a canoe, but with a bit of clear instruction it becomes a small step.
Bridging the knowledge gap
I’m careful about words like “mistake”. Beginners aren’t doing it wrong; they just haven’t been shown the simple things yet. Like the fact that paddling far from the hull creates turning and paddling close helps you hold a line. Or that a single-bladed paddle needs a hand on the grip and another shoulder-width on the shaft while your torso does the real work. Our responsibility as instructors is to give just enough information to make the first experience successful. Success makes it enjoyable, and enjoyment makes people come back.
The forward stroke lightbulb moment
There is a moment I love when the forward stroke clicks. Years ago, I went to what I thought was an advanced paddling course. The instructor handed out PVC pipes and told us to slide them over our elbows and in that moment, it was clear that we were going back to basics. Paddle without your elbows. It felt robotic at first, then surprisingly natural as we loosened the wrists, engaged the torso and let the shoulders rotate. When we took the pipes off and kept the form, everything changed!
Most beginners move water down, then back a bit, then up again. Two thirds of that effort is wasted. When you rotate well and plant the blade cleanly, you finally move water straight back. The boat surges and you feel it and that is the lightbulb moment. The best part is how you feel at the end of a long day; you’ve moved better and your body thanks you for it.
Kneeling, healing and the internet
We posted a recent video of me on our social media channels paddling solo, kneeling, heeling the boat and feathering the blade. Then comments rolled in. “Sit up straight”. “Use a double-blade". “Stop dragging the paddle”. “Put the boat flat”. It’s funny until you remember that these people have never felt the body mechanics at play. Kneeling connects your lower body to the hull. The canoe becomes an extension of you. Power flows from the bottom up, and the paddle is just the last link in the chain. That’s the complete package. It also looks good, and canoeing should look good. Not out of vanity, but because grace and fluidity are signs of efficiency; it should look effortless.at makes an adventure truly memorable.
My first battles with the J-Stroke
I hated the J-stroke at first. I had been paddling for years and felt fine without it. Then for my canoe guide training, an instructor told me I should be using it because it was more efficient. I tried it. It hurt. I couldn’t see the benefit. I did it while he watched and stopped when he turned away.
Later, another teacher gave me two small gems that solved the pain and showed me the difference the stroke makes when done well. Since then, I’ve had the proof I need. On courses where I am solo and everyone else is in tandems, I have to work to keep up once their form improves. Without a good J-stroke I’ll get left behind. With it, I’m right there. The gain is subtle but undeniable.
From fighting the boat to moving as a team
When I teach pairs, I give both paddlers tools that influence direction and I insist on communication. I don’t script what they should say, I just make it clear they need to talk and listen. You can tell when it clicks. They stop fighting each other and start reading each other. Sometimes they don’t say a word; the movement becomes shared and smooth, like synchronised swimmers who happen to be attached to the same hull.
Why everyone should learn to paddle solo
guides, and if you guide, you need solo skills. People get sick. Numbers go odd. You might have to paddle alone. It wasn’t always required in the curriculum, but I taught it anyway and helped get it written in later. Solo paddling shows you where the steering is broken because there is no one else to blame. Fix that and you become a better paddler. When you go back to tandem, you bring efficiency, empathy and confidence with you.
And then there’s the best part about canoes; versatility. One boat can take one person, two people, sometimes three. The same hull I teach in can carry our whole family of four on a day trip. That kind of flexibility builds affection for the craft. It also makes my job easier when I am trying to help someone choose their first boat.
Why efficiency matters
Efficiency is a reward for effort. Think of waxing skis or choosing light shoes for a long hike. Canoeing should look and feel easy because it can be. When you move cleanly and keep the blade working straight back, you waste less energy and go further with less strain. I don’t chase speed for its own sake. If I wanted fast, I would be in a surf ski. What I do want is to move as well as the hull will allow.
I balance the technical with the fun by watching faces. Attention spans have limits. I teach a couple of skills, then we go use them. Not on a tiny patch of lake but on a small journey somewhere beautiful. We learn in the places we paddle because the point of all this is to go to good places well.
Lessons beyond the river
A mate of mine once had a poster on his wall that said, “take something hard, make it harder, then make it look easy”. Canoeing is a bit like that. You handicap yourself with a single blade in a boat that does not naturally track. Make it harder by paddling solo and heeling the hull. Then learn the precision that makes it all feel smooth. The process carries into the rest of life. When something looks hard, I try to name the skills, practise them and make the task feel easy. If we‘re talking tandem specifically, the life lesson is patience, clear communication and playing to each other’s strengths.
A lifetime of learning
I haven’t mastered canoeing. Last week in the wind, threading between trees, I caught myself favouring my right side for the surgical moves. I told myself to switch and do it left. Suddenly I felt like a beginner again, trying to recall my own cues. It was humbling and brilliant. Add in the fact that every craft teaches you something new. Put me in a high-kneel sprint canoe and I swim more than I paddle. It is perfect. It means there is a lifetime of improvement ahead.
That is what keeps me motivated. There is always another small lightbulb moment waiting. Another subtle efficiency to find. Another way to explain a stroke so it finally clicks for someone who thought they could not do it. And then they glide, smile and look up at the cliffs. That’s the good stuff.
Subscribe to our newsletter to hear the latest from the Valley Outdoors team and get a 10% discount on canoe hire.
Sign Up HereReady to put these lessons into practice? Whether you’re a first-time paddler or looking to refine your J-stroke, our guided canoe experiences in Kangaroo Valley are designed to build skills, confidence, and unforgettable memories. Book your next canoe adventure today.
